Feb 8 – What do you remember about falling in love for the first time?
Throughout my pre-teen and teen years, I found myself infatuated with girls. I thought this one was cute and that one would be really cool to get to know better. But because I was so extremely shy and awkward without the benefit of strong men in my life, I never took the plunge and asked a girl out on a date.
When I got to college, I joined a fraternity — one of the best decisions I ever made — and found myself interacting with more women. I also found that I needed to ask girls out on dates more often. Generally, I would ask girls that I was already friends with in order to keep things relaxed and low stress. Then I met her….
I was probably in my senior year when I first met a beautiful young woman and truly got to know her. We had several classes together and shared the stage from time to time. I was quite comfortable around her. I think our first “date” was a non-date. I had bought a couple of tickets to see Miss Saigon in Hollywood for me and a fraternity brother. Something came up and he wasn’t able to go….so I decided to ask her to join me instead. It was a nice evening and very laid back.
As I began to realize that I was developing feelings for this talented woman, I finally worked up the courage to ask her out. There was a group event coming up that I needed to attend and plus-ones were expected. I asked her to the event and she said yes. I was over the moon…..for a little while anyway…..
What I didn’t know (although it was assumed that I did)…..was that my roommate and best friend was also interested in the same girl. Andy had also asked the same woman to the same event within an hour of my invite. Oh crap! Andy was furious and the young woman was confused. I think she saw or heard the fireworks as she walked by our apartment. Anyway, she called me later that evening to talk about things. While she wanted to go to the event — it was a really neat activity in Los Angeles that several of her friends were also going to — she didn’t want to be the cause of conflict between the two of us guys.
So I played the part of the mature one and said that I was totally in the wrong. I told her that Andy had mentioned that he was going to ask her out and I had just misunderstood that the invitation was for this event. I swallowed my pride and told her that I was willing to withdraw my invite so she could accept Andy’s. I assured her that there would be no hurt feelings and that this would not make things awkward between us. What else could I do? Andy was the handsome guy that I could actually see her having a future with (although the two of them did not end up in a long-term relationship ultimately). I then proceeded to tell Andy that his friendship was more important to me than a single date with a girl…..and that he should talk to her again. I anticipated that she would give him a positive answer this time.
In reality, I was heart-broken. I hadn’t told anyone that I was really falling hard for this girl. Honestly, I had not yet admitted it to myself. The event was fun, but it was also awkward. I wanted to be sitting with her, but also felt I needed to give my roommate some space after the awkward turn of events. I was very glad to return to Malibu and let life get back to normal.
Andy’s interest in this young woman was short-lived. There were other dates, but nothing serious ever developed. Ultimately, Andy and I would leave Pepperdine on bad terms that would take years to mend. Truthfully, our friendship has never recovered from the strain we experienced at the end of our college careers. Both Andy and the object of our mutual affections (at the time) are now happily married. I couldn’t be happier for both of them. But I will always wonder “what if” about the first time I asked a woman out that I truly had feelings for that were greater than that of just friendship.